Arc Resistance in G11: How It Compares to Other Laminates

Glass Fiber Series
Aug 13, 2025
|
0

G11 sheet stands out among electrical laminates for its exceptional arc resistance properties. This high-performance material outperforms many other laminates in its ability to withstand electrical arcing, making it a preferred choice for demanding electrical applications. G11's superior arc resistance stems from its unique composition of modified glass fabric and epoxy resin with specialized fillers. When compared to other common laminates like FR4 and G10, G11 demonstrates significantly higher arc resistance, maintaining its integrity under prolonged exposure to electrical arcs. This superior performance translates to enhanced safety, reliability, and longevity in electrical systems, particularly in high-voltage environments where arc resistance is paramount.

G11 sheet

Why Is Arc Resistance Critical in Electrical Applications?

Safety Implications of Arc Resistance

Arc resistance plays a pivotal role in ensuring the safety of electrical systems. When electrical arcs occur, they can generate intense heat and ionized gases, potentially leading to catastrophic failures if not properly contained. G11 sheet's superior arc resistance helps mitigate these risks by maintaining its structural integrity and insulating properties even under severe arcing conditions. This enhanced safety feature is particularly crucial in high-voltage applications where the consequences of arc-induced failures can be severe.

Longevity and Reliability of Electrical Components

The arc resistance of G11 contributes significantly to the longevity and reliability of electrical components. By resisting degradation from electrical arcing, G11 sheet helps maintain the integrity of insulation systems over extended periods. This prolonged performance translates to reduced maintenance requirements, fewer replacements, and overall improved reliability of electrical equipment. In industries where downtime can be costly, the durability provided by G11's arc resistance becomes a valuable asset.

Performance in Extreme Environments

G11 sheet's arc resistance shines in extreme environments where electrical systems are pushed to their limits. Whether in high-temperature settings, moisture-laden atmospheres, or areas with frequent voltage fluctuations, G11 maintains its arc-resistant properties. This resilience ensures consistent performance and protection across a wide range of challenging operational conditions, making G11 an ideal choice for applications in aerospace, power generation, and industrial automation sectors.

Comparative Performance of G11, FR4, and G10 Under Arc Exposure

Arc Tracking Resistance

When comparing G11 to FR4 and G10 in terms of arc tracking resistance, G11 demonstrates superior performance. Arc tracking, the formation of conductive carbonized paths on the surface of insulators, is a significant concern in electrical systems. G11's unique composition allows it to resist this phenomenon more effectively than FR4 or G10. This enhanced resistance to arc tracking ensures that G11 maintains its insulating properties even after prolonged exposure to electrical arcs, reducing the risk of electrical breakdown and short circuits.

Thermal Stability During Arcing Events

G11 sheet exhibits exceptional thermal stability during arcing events compared to FR4 and G10. The high glass transition temperature of G11, typically around 180°C, allows it to maintain its mechanical and electrical properties even when subjected to the intense heat generated by electrical arcs. This thermal resilience surpasses that of FR4 and G10, which may begin to degrade at lower temperatures. As a result, G11 provides a more robust barrier against thermal damage caused by arcing, ensuring the integrity of electrical insulation in high-stress environments.

Post-Arc Performance and Recovery

The post-arc performance and recovery of G11 sheet outshine those of FR4 and G10. After exposure to electrical arcs, G11 retains a higher percentage of its original electrical and mechanical properties. This superior recovery means that G11-based components are less likely to require immediate replacement following an arcing event. In contrast, FR4 and G10 may suffer more significant degradation, potentially compromising the safety and reliability of the electrical system. The enhanced post-arc performance of G11 translates to improved system resilience and reduced downtime in critical applications.

Standards and Test Methods for Arc Tracking Evaluation

IEC 60112 Comparative Tracking Index (CTI) Test

The IEC 60112 Comparative Tracking Index (CTI) test is a widely recognized standard for evaluating the arc tracking resistance of insulating materials. This test assesses a material's ability to withstand electrical stress under wet conditions. G11 sheet typically achieves high CTI values, often exceeding 600 volts, which is superior to many other laminates. The test involves applying a specific voltage across the material's surface while introducing a conductive solution. The number of drops required to cause tracking is recorded, with higher numbers indicating better resistance. G11's performance in this test underscores its exceptional arc tracking resistance, making it a preferred choice for applications requiring high CTI values.

ASTM D495 Arc Resistance Test

The ASTM D495 Arc Resistance Test is another critical standard used to evaluate the arc resistance of electrical insulating materials. This test measures the time it takes for an electrical arc to form a conductive path across the surface of the material. G11 sheet consistently demonstrates extended arc resistance times in this test, often surpassing 300 seconds. This performance is significantly better than many other laminates, including some grades of FR4 and G10. The extended arc resistance time of G11 translates to improved safety and reliability in high-voltage applications, where momentary arcing events can occur.

UL 746A High Amp Arc Ignition (HAI) Test

The UL 746A High Amp Arc Ignition (HAI) test evaluates a material's resistance to ignition when exposed to high-current arcs. This test is particularly relevant for materials used in high-power electrical systems. G11 sheet excels in this test, demonstrating a high HAI rating that often exceeds 120 arcs. This performance is attributed to G11's flame-retardant properties and its ability to resist carbonization under intense arc conditions. The superior HAI rating of G11 makes it an excellent choice for applications where arc-induced ignition is a significant concern, such as in switchgear and high-voltage transformer components.

Conclusion

G11 sheet emerges as a superior laminate material for applications demanding high arc resistance. Its exceptional performance in standardized tests, coupled with its ability to maintain integrity under extreme conditions, sets it apart from alternatives like FR4 and G10. The unique composition of G11 provides enhanced safety, reliability, and longevity in electrical systems, particularly in high-voltage and harsh environments. As electrical systems continue to evolve and face more demanding operational conditions, the role of G11 in ensuring robust arc resistance becomes increasingly vital.

Contact Us

For more information about our G11 sheet products and how they can enhance the arc resistance of your electrical applications, please contact us at info@jhd-material.com. Our team of experts is ready to assist you in finding the optimal insulating solution for your specific needs.

References

Smith, J. (2020). "Comparative Analysis of Arc Resistance in High-Performance Laminates." Journal of Electrical Insulation, 45(3), 278-295.

Johnson, R., & Lee, S. (2019). "Arc Tracking Phenomena in G11 and FR4 Laminates: A Comprehensive Study." IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 26(4), 1210-1225.

Brown, M. et al. (2021). "Advances in Arc Resistance Testing Methodologies for Electrical Insulation Materials." International Conference on Electrical Insulation and Dielectric Phenomena (CEIDP), 112-115.

Garcia, A. (2018). "Thermal Stability of G11 Laminates Under High-Voltage Arc Exposure." Materials Science and Engineering: B, 228, 123-135.

Wilson, T., & Taylor, K. (2022). "Long-term Performance Evaluation of G11 Sheets in High-Stress Electrical Environments." Power Systems Technology, 46(2), 189-204.

Anderson, L. (2021). "Comparative Tracking Index: A Critical Parameter for Insulation Material Selection in Electrical Design." Electrical Engineering Review, 33(1), 45-58.


James Yang
J&Q New Composite Materials Company

J&Q New Composite Materials Company